Building vs Buying First Home: Which Option Saves You More in the Long Run?

The decision between building vs buying first home impacts your finances, lifestyle, and long-term savings. Each option comes with different costs, investment potential, and flexibility. Understanding these factors helps determine which choice saves more in the long run.

Understanding the Costs Involved

Upfront Expenses

Buying an existing home means you’ll need a deposit, stamp duty, legal fees, and possibly lender’s mortgage insurance (LMI) if your deposit is below 20%. Builders, on the other hand, typically require progress payments at different construction stages, and costs can vary depending on the builder, materials, and land preparation requirements. Brooklyn Homes provides guidance on budgeting to help you plan effectively.

Building also comes with hidden costs, such as site preparation, council approvals, and unexpected construction delays. While first-home buyers may be eligible for government grants and concessions that ease some of these costs, budgeting for unforeseen expenses is crucial. Brooklyn Homes provides guidance with the home-building process, helping you understand what to expect from start to finish.

Pro Tip: When building, always budget for hidden costs like site preparation, council fees, and potential delays. A contingency fund of at least 10-15% of your budget can help cover unexpected expenses without financial strain.

‍

Ongoing Maintenance and Repairs

A newly built home generally has lower maintenance costs in the first few years since everything is brand new and under warranty. Energy-efficient appliances and modern materials can also reduce running costs.

Buying an older home can mean dealing with aging infrastructure, potential repairs, and renovations to update outdated features. However, established homes may already have landscaping, fencing, and driveways in place, reducing additional post-purchase expenses.

Pro Tip: Newly built homes usually come with warranties, but maintenance costs increase over time. If buying an existing home, set aside at least 1% of the property’s value annually for future repairs.

‍

Long-Term Financial Implications

The financial impact of building vs buying extends beyond the initial costs. New homes are often more energy-efficient, which can lead to lower utility bills over time. Additionally, buyers may have greater depreciation benefits if they choose to rent out the property later.

On the other hand, established homes in well-located areas tend to appreciate steadily. The demand for properties in developed neighbourhoods with existing amenities can drive up resale value faster than newly developed estates.

‍

Customisation vs Convenience

Flexibility in Design and Features

Building a home allows complete control over the design, layout, and features. From open-plan living spaces to smart home integrations, you can tailor every detail to suit your preferences and future needs.

With an existing home, you may need to compromise on certain aspects. Renovations can help customise the space, but they come with additional costs and potential council approvals. The advantage is that the property is already built, saving you the time and stress of construction.

‍

Immediate Availability and Established Infrastructure

Buying an existing home means you can move in almost immediately after settlement, avoiding the hassle of temporary accommodation. Established homes are often located in well-developed areas with schools, shopping centres, and transport links already in place.

New builds, especially in developing suburbs, may take years for surrounding infrastructure to catch up. While you get a brand-new home, you may have to wait for amenities like parks, public transport, and shopping hubs to be fully developed.

‍

Market Conditions and Investment Potential

How Location Affects Value Growth

Location is a key factor in how much your home appreciates over time. Established areas with strong demand tend to see consistent value growth, making buying a home in these locations a solid investment.

New estates, on the other hand, can be riskier. While land prices may rise as the area develops, some outer suburbs experience slower growth due to oversupply. Researching market trends in your chosen location is essential.

Pro Tip: Research upcoming infrastructure projects, school zones, and transport links in your preferred area. Properties near planned developments often experience faster capital growth over time.

‍

Resale Considerations for Built vs Bought Homes

If you plan to sell in the future, consider how each option affects resale value. A well-maintained established home in a desirable area can attract buyers more easily.

New builds can be appealing, but they may face stiff competition if many similar homes are constructed nearby. Unique design elements and high-quality finishes can set a new home apart when it comes time to sell.

‍

Financing and Government Incentives

Loan Structures and Interest Rate Impact

Home loans for buying and building differ slightly. When purchasing an existing home, you take out a standard mortgage with fixed or variable rates.

Building loans are structured with progressive drawdowns, meaning you pay interest only on the amount used during each stage of construction. This can help manage costs, but interest rates on construction loans may be higher. Once the home is completed, the loan converts to a standard mortgage.

Grants and Benefits for First-Time Buyers

First-home buyers in Australia can access various grants and incentives, including the First Home Owner Grant (FHOG) and stamp duty concessions. Some states offer higher grants for those building new homes, making it a more attractive option financially.

However, these incentives vary by location and eligibility criteria, so checking what’s available in your state is important when weighing up the costs.

‍

Lifestyle and Timing Considerations

Construction Timelines vs Ready-to-Move-In Homes

Building a home requires patience. Construction timelines can range from several months to over a year, depending on the builder, weather conditions, and approval processes. Delays can be frustrating, especially if you’re renting or living with family in the meantime. Brooklyn Homes offers a streamlined building process to help minimise delays and keep your project on track.

Buying an existing home provides certainty. Once settlement is complete, you can move in straight away, making it a more practical choice if you need housing quickly. However, if you’re willing to wait, working with an experienced builder like Brooklyn Homes can ensure your new home is built to match your lifestyle and preferences.

Pro Tip: If building, factor in the cost of temporary accommodation, storage, or extended rental agreements. Some builders offer fixed-timeframe contracts, reducing the risk of unexpected delays.

‍

Impact on Living Expenses and Temporary Housing Needs

If you’re building, you may need to cover rent or alternative housing costs while waiting for construction to finish. This adds to your overall expenses and can stretch your budget.

Buying means you start paying your mortgage immediately, but you avoid the double cost of rent and construction payments. If stability and immediate savings matter, purchasing a home might be the better option.

‍

Key Takeaways

Both building and buying a home come with advantages and challenges. Building offers personalisation, modern features, and potential grants but requires time and patience. Buying provides convenience, established locations, and immediate occupancy but may come with higher maintenance costs.

Whether building or buying, the right choice depends on your financial goals, lifestyle, and long-term plans. If you're leaning towards building, Brooklyn Homes provides expert guidance and home designs to support you through the journey.